Caribbean Islands - Where do you recommend?

This week we had the following inquiry:

My BF and I are thinking about going to the Caribbean on vacation soon. Can you advise me what is that best island to visit as far as being gay friendly and having the most nightlife and beautiful beaches catering to Gays?

About.com has some suggestions where they suggest the five most gay friendly islands.

• St Barts
• St. Martin/St. Maarten
• Puerto Rico
• U.S. Virgin Islands 
• Curacao

If you look at the IGLTA website those sites with the most IGLTA members from these five are from top to bottom:

Curacao

Puerto Rico

U.S. Virgin Islands 

St. Martin/St. Maarten

St Barts

We would love our readers thoughts on this topic so please feel free to answer the questions below using our comment section. 

• What is your  favourite Caribbean Island?
  
• The best gay night life
  
• The best gay beaches
  
• The best island for lesbians
  
• The best island for Rainbow Families